Monday, March 10, 2014

Organizing the data: countywide Felton vacancy

This candidate is unopposed in the upcoming Democratic primary; no Republican filed for this vacancy.
Updated 3/13/14

Patricia O'Brien Sheahan -- #148


Campaign Website

Candidate Statement: Patricia O'Brien Sheahan: In her own words

Bar Association Evaluations
The Chicago Bar Association says:
Patricia O’Brien Sheahan is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Sheahan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1996 and was engaged in private practice as an Associate in a large law firm before becoming Associate General Counsel of the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago. Ms. Sheahan has a wide range of practice experience and supervises and handles litigation for the Rehabilitation Institute. Ms. Sheahan possesses the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Patricia O’Brien Sheahan was admitted to practice in 1996. She is currently the Associate General Counsel of the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, where she oversees all litigation and claims made against her employer and its employees. She handles case investigations, pretrial discovery, and settlement negotiation. She handles and defends all employment/labor matters and claims before the EEOC, Illinois Department of Human Rights, and other administrative tribunals, including preparation and questioning of witnesses. She has prepared appellate briefs filed in both the Illinois Supreme Court and in the Illinois Appellate Court. From 1996 to 1999 she was a litigation associate with Baker & McKenzie in Chicago, working in the litigation and employment litigation practice groups. She reports that during her time at Baker, she first chaired a jury trial, represented clients in evidentiary proceedings, defended and took more than 50 depositions, and had an active motion practice. She is active in community affairs. Lawyers report that she has good legal ability and is praised for the quality of her work product. She is considered to be knowledgeable, and always prepared. In general, Ms. Sheahan is considered to be a very good lawyer and case manager with experience in a variety of state and federal litigation matters. The Council finds her Qualified for the Circuit Court.
Other Bar Association Evaluations:
Asian American Bar Association of the
Greater Chicago Area
Not Evaluated
Black Women Lawyers’ Association of Greater ChicagoNot Evaluated
Cook County Bar AssociationRecommended
Decalogue Society of LawyersRecommended
Hellenic Bar AssociationRecommended
Hispanic Lawyers Association of IllinoisNot Recommended
Illinois State Bar AssociationNot Qualified
Lesbian and Gay Bar Association of ChicagoRecommended
Puerto Rican Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended
Women’s Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended

------------------------------------------------------
Back to "Start here for the most complete information about every Cook County judicial contest"

James Patrick Crawley interviewed on an NTNM Election Special



Countywide candidate James Patrick Crawley (Veal vacancy) was interviewed by Avy Meyers for a North Town News Magazine Election Special and this interview has now been posted online. With the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

This is the second time that Crawley has been interviewed on NTNM in this election cycle. You can see his earlier interview by following this link.

Organizing the Data: countywide Howse vacancy

This candidate is unopposed in the upcoming Democratic primary; no Republican filed for this vacancy.

Caroline Kate Moreland -- #149

Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluations
The Chicago Bar Association says:
Judge Caroline Kate Moreland is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Moreland was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 14 years before becoming a judge. Judge Moreland is well respected and possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Hon. Caroline Moreland was admitted to practice in Illinois in November 1995. From 1996-2010 she worked as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney. She was appointed to the bench to fill a judicial vacancy in September 2010. As a prosecutor, Judge Moreland was considered to have good legal ability and temperament. She prosecuted felony matters as a First Chair prosecutor. The Council finds her Qualified for the Circuit Court.
Other Bar Association Evaluations:
Asian American Bar Association of the
Greater Chicago Area
Qualified
Black Women Lawyers’ Association of Greater ChicagoRecommended
Cook County Bar AssociationRecommended
Decalogue Society of LawyersHighly Recommended
Hellenic Bar AssociationRecommended
Hispanic Lawyers Association of IllinoisQualified
Illinois State Bar AssociationQualified
Lesbian and Gay Bar Association of ChicagoRecommended
Puerto Rican Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended
Women’s Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended

------------------------------------------------------
Back to "Start here for the most complete information about every Cook County judicial contest"


Katherine A. O'Dell interviewed on an NTNM Election Special



Tenth Subcircuit candidate Katherine A. O'Dell was interviewed by Avy Meyers for a North Town News Magazine Election Special and this interview has now been posted online. With the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

This is the third time that O'Dell has been interviewed on NTNM in this election cycle. You can see her earlier interviews here and here.

Organizing the Data: countywide Lowrance vacancy

This candidate is unopposed in the upcoming Democratic primary; no Republican filed for this vacancy.

Thomas J. Carroll -- #150

Bar Association Evaluations
The Chicago Bar Association says:
Judge Thomas Joseph Carroll is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Carroll was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and was appointed a judge in September 2011. Judge Carroll is currently assigned to Traffic Court and has received favorable reviews from lawyers appearing in his court. Judge Carroll has a fine temperament and possesses the legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Hon. Thomas Joseph Carroll was admitted in 1988. He was appointed to the Circuit Court by the Illinois Supreme Court in 2011. He was an Assistant Public Defender for four years, moving from juvenile to misdemeanor to felony work. He had been a sole practitioner specializing in criminal defense. Mr. Carroll is reported to have good legal ability and temperament. Before becoming a judge he had substantial litigation experience in both civil and criminal law matters.
He is praised as being hard-working and well prepared. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
Other Bar Association Evaluations:
Asian American Bar Association of the
Greater Chicago Area
Qualified
Black Women Lawyers’ Association of Greater ChicagoRecommended
Cook County Bar AssociationRecommended
Decalogue Society of LawyersRecommended
Hellenic Bar AssociationRecommended
Hispanic Lawyers Association of IllinoisQualified
Illinois State Bar AssociationQualified
Lesbian and Gay Bar Association of ChicagoRecommended
Puerto Rican Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended
Women’s Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended

------------------------------------------------------
Back to "Start here for the most complete information about every Cook County judicial contest"

Anjana Hansen interviewed on an NTNM Election Special



Ninth Subcircuit candidate Anjana Hansen (Meyer vacancy) was interviewed by Avy Meyers for a North Town News Magazine Election Special and this interview has now been posted online. With the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

This is the second time that Hansen has been interviewed on NTNM in this election cycle. You can see her earlier interview by following this link.

Organizing the Data: 7th Subcircuit, Hardy-Campbell vacancy

This candidate is unopposed in the upcoming Democratic primary; no Republican filed for this vacancy.
Robert D. Kuzas -- #171

Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluations
The Chicago Bar Association says:
Robert D. Kuzas is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Kuzas was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1989 and is engaged in private practice concentrating in criminal law and personal injury matters. Mr. Kuzas has both criminal and civil jury trial experience and is well regarded by opposing counsel and the judges before whom he appears. Mr. Kuzas has an outstanding temperament and possesses the depth and breadth of experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Robert Kuzas was admitted to practice in 1989. He is currently a solo practitioner where he focuses on criminal defense, personal injury, and labor relations cases. He has been in private practice throughout his career. Mr. Kuzas has substantial experience in a variety of more complex litigation matters. He is considered to have good legal ability and temperament. He is praised for his litigation skills. He is reported to be exceptionally hard-working and knowledgeable. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
Other Bar Association Evaluations:
Asian American Bar Association of the
Greater Chicago Area
Qualified
Black Women Lawyers’ Association of Greater ChicagoRecommended
Cook County Bar AssociationRecommended
Decalogue Society of LawyersRecommended
Hellenic Bar AssociationRecommended
Hispanic Lawyers Association of IllinoisHighly Qualified
Illinois State Bar AssociationQualified
Lesbian and Gay Bar Association of ChicagoHighly Recommended
Puerto Rican Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended
Women’s Bar Association of IllinoisRecommended

------------------------------------------------------
Back to "Start here for the most complete information about every Cook County judicial contest"

Judge Peter Vilkelis interviewd on an NTNM Election Special



Judge Peter J. Vilkelis, a candidate for the countywide Connors vacancy, was interviewed by Avy Meyers for a North Town News Magazine Election Special and this interview has now been posted online. With the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

This is the second time that Vilkelis has been interviewed on NTNM in this election cycle. You can see his earlier interview by following this link.

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

What's in a name? King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite denied British passport


The Briton formerly known as Mathew Whelan, a 34-year old Lib Dem activist from Birmingham, changed his name to King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite in 2009, according to Sara Malm's story posted Sunday on The Daily Mail. Malm writes that "Body Art" (that's the tattooed one's choice of diminutive for King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite) was able to procure a driver's license bearing his adopted appellation (one wonders whether the length of the driver's license had to be extended as an accommodation) but not a passport.

King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite's old passport had expired, you see, and when he went to renew it using his new name the office had a problem. When the Passport Office questioned the name, requesting further documentation, King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite sent in his driver's license, a registered letter that had been sent and delivered to him (one wonders if the name took up one line or two on the envelope), and a letter from his local MP.

Yes, King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite is being supported in his quest for a new passport bearing this name by his local Member of Parliament. (Several Monty Python sketches come to mind, don't they?)

But Body Art is quite serious about his quest; he insists that denying him his choice of name is a violation of his "human rights."

Malm's article says the Passport Office refused to comment specifically about why it has so far refused to grant a new passport in King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite's name. However, Malm quotes office policy as follows:
Where an applicant changes his or her name to a string of words or phrases that would not normally be recognised as a name, this should not be entered onto the personal details page of the passport.

For example, the names "New Year" "Happy Easter" or "Good Bye" are unacceptable as, when put together, they became a recognised phrase or saying.
I'm not certain how recognizable a phrase or saying "King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite" might be, but I can certainly understand that this string of words might not be normally recognized as a name.

Interestingly, King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite claims to be Britain's most tattooed person, with tattoos over 90% of his body. According to the Daily Mail, King of Ink Land King Body Art The Extreme Ink-Ite even had his left eyeball tattooed black. Body Art has spent more than £25,000 on his extraordinarily personal art project. The reason he's looking for a new passport is that "he has been offered work abroad to turn his hobby into a job," according to the article.

Clerk Brown's office posts virus warning

Click to enlarge
Visitors to the website of Cook County Circuit Court Clerk Dorothy Brown may have noticed the warning reproduced above in recent days. In case you're reading this post on a device that doesn't have a screen large enough to make that snippet legible, here is what the notice says:
IMPORTANT WARNING REGARDING “COURT HEARING” EMAIL SCAM

Please be aware that there is an email scam currently targeting individuals with the following subject line: “Hearing of your case in Court (followed by a number).” The email has an ATTACHMENT, which, if opened, CONTAINS A MALICIOUS COMPUTER VIRUS that will infect your Windows computer. This message is NOT sent by any Court. DO NOT OPEN under any circumstance, DELETE IT from your mailbox.

More information about this virus can be found at: http://www.onlinethreatalerts.com/article/2013/12/23/hearing-of-your-case-in-court-nr-virus-emails.
If you follow the link provided on Clerk Brown's website you will see that this warning does not stem from any compromise in the online notification system that we were all required to sign up for just last year. The Clerk's office is simply providing this warning as a public service for attorneys and others who may not be wise in the ways of technology.

Still... no virus has ever compromised any of the paper files in my office. I have spilled the occasional cup of coffee, but the resulting stains don't necessarily compromise the information stored on the printed pages. I embrace the brave new digital world -- I'm out here in the Ether with you, aren't I? -- but my love of technology is not unconditional. I still worry that so much of our personal and business and professional lives is just one power surge away from destruction, or else at the mercy of some bright, but bored, teenager in Eastern Europe. I don't think that makes me a Luddite, does it?

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Corporate lawyer achieves escape velocity

Image obtained from EVE Online
Debra Cassens Weiss has an article this morning on ABA Journal Law News Now entitled "Lawyer-turned-galactic overlord leaves BigLaw and achieves online success."

Alex Gianturco had a career defending white-collar crime cases for Washington, D.C.-based megafirm Zuckerman Spaeder LLP. But he was dissatisfied. He craved escape.

When James Thurber wrote "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty," the careworn Mr. Mitty could only imagine alternate realities. Mr. Gianturco could immerse himself in computer games. In Gianturco's case, the game of choice was something called EVE Online. In the Wall Street Journal article that inspired Ms. Weiss's post this morning, David Román describes EVE Online as a "popular space-combat game," a "rarity among games based on virtual universes" because, a decade after launch, it has a still-growing subscriber base (at a cost of $14.95 a month).

Gianturco's game persona, The Mittani, scratched and clawed his way to the head of the Goonswarm Alliance, leading, Román writes, "the 37,000 players of the larger CFC coalition." His path to the top of the virtual heap apparently involved stealth and espionage, not swashbuckling and weaponry. But he was still practicing law on his way up. Once Gianturco achieved his virtual success, he jettisoned the day job and moved, with his (presumably very understanding) wife, to Madison, Wisconsin, planning to live off his savings and maintain his precarious hold at the top of the EVE Online heap.

An incident at a 2011 gaming conference in Iceland -- Gianturco admits to being inebriated and "berating" another player -- led him to found his own website, TheMittani.com, covering games generally and the EVE Online universe in particular.

I don't pretend to understand any of this. My kids will tell you that I couldn't get the hang of the most basic Playstation controls when they were growing up. They made fun of my attempts to avoid conflicts and build trade routes in various editions of Sid Meier's Civilization. (You're supposed to start wars, they'd tell me.) And, of course, when I want to escape to a different world, I still sometimes read books. With actual pages and bindings and such.

But I understood this much: Mr. Gianturco has built such a successful website that he has attracted the attention of the Wall Street Journal. He admits to making a "comfortable living" from the ads on TheMittani.com. As the proprietor of a couple of websites, that's certainly enough to fire my imagination....

Saturday, January 11, 2014

Woman sues divorce lawer for failing to advise her that divorce would end her marriage

Several British newspapers -- the Daily Mail, the Daily Mirror, and the Independent, to name three -- are reporting today that a British woman is suing her lawyers for professional negligence (malpractice) because they 'failed' to tell her that getting a divorce would, in fact, end her marriage.

Tomas Jivanda's story in the Independent reports that, among her malpractice claims, Jane Mulcahy charged that her "lawyers failed to regard her Roman Catholic faith and should have recommended judicial separation - a step down from full divorce - as an alternative course of action."

The case did not attract public attention when it was initially dismissed; the story got picked up when the appeal was likewise thrown out.

The story is amusing, another illustration of the idea that people sue for the darndest reasons, and it gives readers something to feel smug about (how could anyone not know that divorce ends marriage? we chortle).

Except, of course, if Mrs. Mulcahy were so devout a Catholic, she would know that even a legal divorce would not end her marriage, not in the eyes of the Church. Perhaps what really upset her was that, once divorced, her ex-husband was free to marry in the eyes of the law, if not the Church -- maybe he did marry -- when a "judicial separation" would have prevented it.

Whatever it might be, there is surely a more accurate explanation for Mrs. Mulcahy's quixotic suit against her divorce lawyers than her (allegedly) not knowing that divorce ends a marriage. The truth probably wouldn't be nearly as amusing; newspapers -- and bloggers -- probably wouldn't be nearly as interested.

But there is a cautionary tale in here for lawyers generally: Clients come to us and tell us what they think they want. Our job isn't just to give them what they ask for, assuming that we can, but to ascertain what they may really want and need. That might not be what they asked for at all. On the Illinois license it says we are attorneys and counselors. Often, we need to be both.

Two steps forward and one step back: Singing the Blue Cart Blues

We were thrilled, of course, when we finally got our genuine, official Chicago blue cart for recycling, the first serious recycling program here on the Northwest Side of Chicago since our pilot "blue bins" program was discontinued some 20 years ago or more.

You'll note that I do not mention the "blue bag" fantasy years. Even those who believed firmly in faerie circles and unicorn glades had trouble accepting the idea that recyclables protected only by blue plastic bags would really be recycled when they saw them smashed in the back of the same truck that compacted the rest of the garbage. Especially when the mandatory blue bags were just a bit thinner than the typical plastic trash bag, and significantly more expensive.

Anyway, for years and years, anyone wanting to really recycle had to bring their stuff to giant bins set up at a handful of locations around the City -- Caldwell Woods, for example, at Milwaukee and Devon. These were almost always overflowing. (Recently, perhaps in recognition of this fact, the City had set up another bin at the 41st Ward yard on Higgins.) The alternative was to bring the family recycling to the homes of friends and relatives in more enlightened municipalities. Park Ridge is close by. Park Ridge has had blue carts for years.

But, finally, we had our own blue cart. It seemed the dawning of the Age of Aquarius.

Except...

Well, the first disappointment was that the blue carts would only be picked up every other week. We didn't realize, at first, the problems that this would cause.

Our blue cart was proudly stuffed to overflowing for the first pick-up. It was overflowing, too, for the second pick-up. And the third. In the meantime, stuff that wouldn't fit was piling up in the garage. Fortunately, Hoarders has been cancelled; I was starting to worry that their location scouts would start prowling around.

Finally, on a snowy weekend afternoon around Christmas, my son Jim and I filled the family van with cardboard and shredded paper and other recyclables that never seemed to fit in the blue cart and headed over to the 41st Ward Yard to get rid of the surplus.

But the giant bin was gone.

We went to Caldwell Woods.

Both giant bins were gone.

Why? Why would the City discontinue collecting stuff it can sell? Did the City tie itself up with a non-compete clause when it signed up with Waste Management to belatedly expand the blue cart program?

Defeated, we returned all our stuff to the garage.

We got rid of it today.

The City did not make our regular garbage pickup yesterday. That was no surprise, not even a disappointment. We've had some extreme weather in these parts, two feet of snow and freezing cold, and these recent "Chiberian" conditions stretched the resources of the Department of Streets and San to the breaking point. But looking out at the curb this morning, looking at the overflowing blue cart and the half empty black cart, and knowing there was another entirely empty black cart emerging from a melting snowdrift on the side of the house, something in me snapped.

I threw all the cardboard out. Anything I couldn't wedge in the blue cart went into the black carts. All were overflowing before I was done. I know it was wrong. But I think it was necessary.

Now if we could just get an electronics recycling day scheduled somewhere nearby, I might get my garage back. Meanwhile I'm singing the Blue Cart Blues....

Thursday, January 2, 2014

'What did you do at work today' can be a dangerous (and expensive) question for a lawyer: A likely case in point

The Chicago Tribune reports this evening that the Solicitors Regulation Authority has "issued a written rebuke" and hit a British lawyer, Chris Gossage, a partner at Russells Solicitors, with a fine of £1,000 (roughly $1,650) for revealing that J.K. Rowling, the creator of the Harry Potter series, had published a detective novel last year under a pseudonym.

Rowling wanted to publish a book without having it compared to her Harry Potter heptalogy. So, just like any self-respecting billionaire author, Rowling arranged with her publisher, Little Brown, to have The Cuckoo's Calling published under the fictitious name of Robert Galbraith, complete with an extensive publicity campaign about the "first-time" author, supposedly a former plainclothes Royal Military Police investigator who had left the force in 2003 to work in the civilian security industry.

"Galbraith's" book got good reviews -- which Ms. Rowling found quite gratifying -- but not many copies were sold (somewhere between 500 and 1,500 depending on the source consulted).

Sales were weak, that is, until lawyer Gossage let slip to his wife, or to his wife's BFF, one Judith Callegari, that Rowling was the real author. Either way, Callegari tweeted the juicy tidbit to a British journalist and author, India Knight, and the secret unraveled soon thereafter. Once this happened, Wikipedia notes, "sales of the book rose by 4000 percent, and Little Brown printed an additional 140,000 copies to meet the increase in demand."

Naturally, Rowling was devastated by the unauthorized disclosure, and infuriated. She sued Callegari, Gossage and Gossage's firm.

OK, the rich really are different from you and me. (Rowling's suit settled with the firm making a substantial donation to a charity designated by Rowling.)

But the point is that Rowling had the right to publish her book under any name she wanted -- and she had every reason to expect that her lawyers would respect her right to use the pseudonym. With few exceptions, lawyers in Britain and Illinois alike are required to maintain client confidences.

In Illinois, lawyers confidentiality obligations are set out at Rule 1.6 of our Rules of Professional Conduct.

Rule 1.6 provides:
(a) A lawyer shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a client unless the client gives informed consent, the disclosure is impliedly authorized in order to carry out the representation, or the disclosure is permitted by paragraph (b) or required by paragraph (c).

(b) A lawyer may reveal information relating to the representation of a client to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary:
(1) to prevent the client from committing a crime in circumstances other than those specified in paragraph (c);

(2) to prevent the client from committing fraud that is reasonably certain to result in substantial injury to the financial interests or property of another and in furtherance of which the client has used or is using the lawyer’s services;

(3) to prevent, mitigate or rectify substantial injury to the financial interests or property of another that is reasonably certain to result or has resulted from the client’s commission of a crime or fraud in furtherance of which the client has used the lawyer’s services;

(4) to secure legal advice about the lawyer’s compliance with these Rules;

(5) to establish a claim or defense on behalf of the lawyer in a controversy between the lawyer and the client, to establish a defense to a criminal charge or civil claim against the lawyer based upon conduct in which the client was involved, or to respond to allegations in any proceeding concerning the lawyer’s representation of the client; or

(6) to comply with other law or a court order.
(c) A lawyer shall reveal information relating to the representation of a client to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm.

(d) Information received by a lawyer participating in a meeting or proceeding with a trained intervener or panel of trained interveners of an approved lawyers’ assistance program, or in an intermediary program approved by a circuit court in which nondisciplinary complaints against judges or lawyers can be referred, shall be considered information relating to the representation of a client for purposes of these Rules.
Even the casual reader will note that there is no exception in the rule for telling your spouse or significant other a really good story. There is no such exemption in Britain either, which is why Mr. Gossage is out £1,000 tonight.

So, to any non-lawyers married or in a relationship with a lawyer: When you ask how things are going at work, or whether anything interesting happened at the office today, and you get a grunt or a shrug or a few meaningless syllables in response, please don't take offense.

Sunday, December 29, 2013

Judicial blogger appears on NTNM



The final round of BCS bowl games will get nearly all the viewers this week, but North Town News Magazine gamely counterprograms with a program including this interview of a cranky old lawyer and judicial blogger.

My thanks to NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh for allowing me to repost this interview. You could, in theory, watch this interview when the show is broadcast in its entirety on CAN TV 19 in Chicago on Thursday, January 2 at 7:30 p.m. (that's when Alabama and Oklahoma are scheduled to kickoff in the Sugar Bowl) or Friday, January 3 at 2:30 p.m. This NTNM program will also air in Evanston on Thursday at 5:00 p.m. and Sunday at 10:30 p.m. and on a number of suburban cable systems on Monday, January 6.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Two stories on ABA Journal Law News Now illustrate the ongoing split in the legal profession

A story caught my eye on ABA Journal Law News Now as I sat at the computer in my den, checking my email and messages from what amounts to my 'home office.' The headline on the post by Debra Cassens Weiss was "Work-at-home lawyer suspended partly for lack of a 'bona fide office'." (I'm home, for the moment, because I have to go to Wisconsin this morning to pick up my youngest son from college.)

I clicked over to read the sad story of Delaware practitioner Fred Barakat, a Pennsylvania resident who had a Wilmington office address in a suite that sounds something like the kind of set-up advertised by Regus (or any of the other 'virtual office' providers) for Chicago lawyers. Having a 'virtual office' is still legal in Illinois -- even where one's attendance at is (like Barakat's) "sporadic and unscheduled" -- but Delaware Supr.Ct. R. 12 requires lawyers to have a "'bona fide' office." A Delaware lawyer complies with this rule by being in the office for "a substantial and scheduled portion of time during ordinary business hours in the traditional work week." A temporary absence (as for a trial, say) does not violate the rule, but the office must be equipped with the "customary facilities for engaging in the practice of law" and must be "more than a mail drop, a summer home which is unattended during a substantial portion of the year or an answering, telephone forwarding, secretarial or similar service."

(What are the customary facilities for the practice of law anyway? A yellow pad or two, some pens, a computer, some law books? My den qualifies on these counts. Abraham Lincoln used to say that his stovepipe hat was his office. Of course, ol' Abe never tried to practice law in Delaware.)

At any event, despite the headline, Mr. Barakat's suspension was not caused solely by his attempt to cut overhead by working from home as much as possible. See, In re Barakat, --- A.2d ---, No. 397, 2013 (Del.Sup.Ct. 12/11/13). Still, a substantial portion of the Delaware court's opinion is devoted to Barakat's office arrangements.

The default sidebar on the ABA Journal Law News Now is a list of the stories most read on the site. My wandering eye noticed this headline there, "More Top Lawyers Break Through $1,000 Hourly Billing Barrier." It turns out that this was actually a 2011 story, also written by Debra Cassens Weiss.

Mr. Barakat, trying to work from home to save the cost of renting an office, and these $1,000 an hour superstars are all allegedly members of the same learned profession.

It's increasingly hard to believe.

Monday, December 16, 2013

Iowa lawyer disciplined after getting caught up in Nigerian inheritance scam

Somehow this old cartoon from the webcomic
Married to the Sea seemed very appropriate here

By now you may have heard about Robert Allan Wright, Jr., the Iowa lawyer who was disciplined December 6 by the Supreme Court of Iowa after getting involved in a Nigerian inheritance scheme. (Iowa Supreme Court Disciplinary Board v. Wright, 2013 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 123 -- this link will get you to the court's opinion, but only until Groundhog's Day).

Wright did not respond to a spam email from the widow of a hitherto unknown "Nigerian general;" he had a flesh and blood client sitting in his office who claimed he'd come into an enormous inheritance from a long lost cousin.

Granted, Wright was representing the client, a man named Madison, in a criminal matter. And, yes, Madison's allegedly dead cousin was in Nigeria. But all Madison had to do, he told Wright, was pay $177,660 in inheritance taxes due and owing; that, and procure an "anti-terrorism certificate," and the very next thing you know, he would come into $18.8 million. For his part in facilitating the transfer, Wright would be paid 10% of the amount recovered.

Apparently it never occurred to Mr. Wright to suggest that the amount of "tax" due be simply deducted from the payout. If it did occur to him, the scammers persuaded him that things could not be done that way.

The Iowa Supreme Court made it clear that Wright was not being disciplined for his mere credulity (slip op. at 9):
Wright is not the first Iowa lawyer who has become entangled in a deception with ostensible Nigerian connections. See Iowa Supreme Ct. Bd. of Prof’l Ethics & Conduct v. Jones, 606 N.W.2d 5, 9 (Iowa 2000) (noting the incidence of fraudulent transactions with purported connections to the country of Nigeria). Lawyers in other jurisdictions have also been entangled and deceived in such schemes in recent years. See, e.g., In re Maxwell, 334 B.R. 736, 738–41 (Bankr. M.D. Fla. 2005); Parker v. Williams, 977 So. 2d 476, 477–78 (Ala. 2007); Lappostato v. Terk, 71 A.3d 552, 559–60 (Conn. App. Ct. 2013); In re Reinstatement of Jones, 203 P.3d 909, 912–13 (Okla. 2009); see also Lucas v. BankAtlantic, 944 So. 2d 1031, 1032 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 2006) (describing a deception originating in Africa).
Instead, where Wright went wrong was in helping Madison to raise money for the "tax" by borrowing money from other clients, sucking them into the scheme. Essentially, he violated rules requiring competence in client representation by failing to see through the inheritance scam, he failed to disclose his pecuniary interest in the scheme to the clients from whom he solicited loans, and he failed to protect the interests of his clients from whom loans were solicited. (Slip op. at 9-13.)

But Wright did not intend to defraud anyone. The Disciplinary Board acknowledged that Wright "clearly believed in the legitimacy of Madison's inheritance." Even as the disciplinary proceedings exposed the folly of his hopes, Wright kept right on believing that "one day a trunk full of . . . one hundred dollar bills is going to appear upon his office doorstep," according to the Disciplinary Board. Wright's conduct might be delusional, the Board asserted, but not fraudulent. (Slip op. at 8-9.) Nevertheless, because of his ethical lapses, Wright will be suspended from the practice of law in Iowa for at least a year.

It's easy to pile on the unfortunate Mr. Wright: All of us receive dubious inheritance proposals and spurious contract claims on a daily basis. We don't fall for them. I've got three new ones in my spam just this morning -- one from someone who is "in the military unit here in Afghanistan" who wants a partner she and her partners can trust to move "some amount of funds" out of the country. It's all legal, my correspondent assures me. A Mr. Buba has $20 million that he wants to move from his country -- he doesn't say which country -- but he'll give me 40% just for arranging the transfer. And Barrister Joshua Yohana from Burkina Faso wants me to help him move $30,400,000 left behind in his country by the late Libyan dictator Muammar al-Gaddafi. The surprising aspect of this morning's spam is that there are no Chinese businessmen who have sure-fire, eight-figure collection cases I can handle for them; I've had a lot of those lately, too.

But... what else is in my email today? The National Law Journal sends me updates morning and evening about superstar lawyers concluding mega-deals. My Twitter feed regularly carries more locally-tinged, but similar, stories from Crain's Chicago Business. And the Chicago Daily Law Bulletin sends me an email every evening where I learn about the latest triumphs of my brothers or sisters in the local bar, many of whom I know.

I wonder if Mr. Wright had a similar experience: He may have seen that there are big cases out there, big deals, enormous paydays for his Iowa brothers and sisters in the law.

But there are only a few rock stars in the law; most of the rest of us are flailing away in garage bands. For every Beatles-like success story, how many thousands of other lawyers remain Quarreymen all their professional lives?

The discrepancies between the top and the bottom of the legal profession are wide, and widening daily. Judges may chafe at the rising tide of pro se litigants in our courts, but many lawyers -- good, competent lawyers who, at one time, would have been engaged by those persons now proceeding pro se -- are drowning beneath that tide.

Litigation has been priced beyond the reach of many prospective clients -- but it is not only they who have suffered as a result.

So, this morning, I can't pile on poor Mr. Wright. I can't condone what he did... but I can understand, perhaps, why he grabbed onto that thin tale of big money with both hands, and kept holding on.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

"Short and to the point" is all well and good -- up to a point

Checking my email this morning from the Blue Line train, I saw an ad for CLE presentations planned for the upcoming ISBA/IJA Joint Meeting. One was designed to help attorneys tighten up their writing skills. A snippet from the ad:
Gone are the long, flowing email messages with pretty graphics and lots of attachments. Today’s communication – almost 100% electronic – is immediate, brief, clear, and powerful. Designed to boost your instant (or near-instant) message drafting skills, this program examines the ways in which lawyers' traditional training in writing and communication ill-prepares them for this new age of "short and to the point."
I certainly understand the need for lawyers to tighten up their prose. One of the many reasons I resisted Twitter for so long was that I didn't think a lawyer can say good morning in fewer than 140 characters. (I'm working on it.)

One of my favorite bloggers, Ken Levine, wrote this useful 2010 piece on the perils of overwriting. Mr. Levine was talking about writing TV scripts, not legal briefs, but his advice applies equally well to legal writing: Trim. Edit. Lose page 8 (OK, that one Levine borrowed from Earl Pomerantz).

As you might expect, judges are often the strongest advocates of shorter, tighter legal writing: They have to wade through our verbiage.

I recall one judge years ago, in DuPage, who threw my 12-page brief back at me on the day appointed for hearing. I didn't think the brief overlong; after all, it was comfortably within the standard 15-page limit observed in many Cook County courts. But I didn't realize that DuPage then had a 10-page limit. (Well, Cook County is bigger than DuPage.)

As he gave me back the brief and reset the hearing date, the learned judge admonished me, "I read this. You could have said this in eight pages."

(I probably resisted the urge to ask, since he'd bothered to read it, why we couldn't have our hearing. Probably. My memory is indistinct on this point. If I didn't resist, I apologize nunc pro tunc.)

I recently had the experience of updating an article I'd first done for the CBA Record back in 1996. If it was good enough to be updated, I reasoned, I should probably keep the length about the same.

My reasoning proved faulty: Publication standards had changed in the last 17 years and I was ordered to lose over a thousand words.

It wasn't exactly easy to lose the first 500 of those words -- it took more than two hours and I felt like a butcher -- but the resulting draft was better for the pruning. Of course, I still had another 5-600 words to go. Each successive pass through the article took just as long as the first 500-word chop -- and never yielded more than a 100 word net loss.

There is a point of diminishing returns: The complexity of the ideas conveyed or the persuasiveness of an argument in a brief, a blog post, or article is of necessity diminished when compressed beyond a certain point. Sloganeering on Facebook or flaming tweets may be "immediate, brief, clear, and powerful" -- but entirely useless for persuasion or rational discussion. See, cable TV news programs. See also, Congress. Truly persuasive arguments must be developed, not hurled like a gauntlet; important facts must be explained, not glossed over. Not everything is black or white; lawyers in particular must distinguish shades of gray. Can we do so more efficiently? Certainly -- but shorter usually takes longer.

My late father was a regular CLE presenter in his day. He'd go on a statewide tour every year, alternating, from year to year, between his employer and IICLE. He told me he could give a two-hour talk on five minutes' notice. If someone wanted him to speak for 15 minutes, however, he'd insist on a week to prepare.

I submit that the same is true for legal writing: Without a deadline for the opinion letter or brief and no ceiling on the number of hours that can be devoted to the project, we could all produce shorter and tighter work product. But will clients really appreciate paying double or triple for a tight two-page letter rather than a faster, cheaper five-page essay? (If you think the answer is 'yes,' you have never dealt with clients.)

Granted, it would be wonderful if lawyers could learn to write better and faster. But "instant (or near-instant) message drafting skills" are not always helpful. I'm old enough to remember when the fax machine was cutting-edge technology. Clients could fax in a problem -- and since it reached us in minutes, they expected a response in minutes as well. Email has only exacerbated the problem.

Yes, there may be some questions that lawyers can answer instantly. And it is surely useful to learn tips on how to turn a blank screen (or blank page) into serviceable prose without undue hemming and hawing.

But the reflex answer is not always the right one. "It depends" is not always a dodge. Sometimes, in trying to explain our initial answer, we realize that we are dealing with an exception to the general rule, or perhaps a different rule than we thought applicable in the first place. "Short and to the point" is a valuable objective -- but not so short that the point is watered down or missed entirely.

Thursday, November 7, 2013

I was really wondering how they could carry an open flame into outer space


Not all that surprising answer: They can't quite do that. Open flames are frowned upon in spacecraft. The Olympic Torch, however, is aboard the International Space Station, however, and will soon be carried on a spacewalk.

(Photo accompanying this post is taken from this NASA Tweet.)

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Australian government employee injured while having sex denied worker's compensation benefits

In the news this past week was the titillating tale of an Australian woman, a government employee, injured while having sex. She sought compensation from her employer as a result of her injuries. The case was in the news because, last Wednesday, Australia's High Court, the country's highest judicial tribunal, issued a decision this week reversing lower court orders which had found the injuries compensable under Australia's Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act of 1988 (that nation's worker's compensation statute).

This item was reported by Chicago media outlets with varying degrees of snickering and innuendo, especially by those who read deeply enough into the original press coverage to discover that the injury occurred when either the woman or her companion (no one really knows for sure) pulled a glass light fixture from its mount above the bed, causing it to strike the woman in the face.

As a lawyer (but not a worker's compensation specialist), I couldn't help but wonder if this fact about someone actively pulling the light fixture from the wall was not just a matter of prurient interest but, rather, a critical factor in the Australian court's analysis: In tort law, this might be referred to as an intervening cause.

The way I looked at it, because the woman had to stay overnight at the motel as part of her work assignment, if the fixture had come loose of its own volition and struck the woman while she was sleeping, she probably would have had no problem collecting worker's compensation benefits (in addition to whatever claim she might have against the motel). Then, I speculated, if the fixture came off on its own, it should have made no difference if she'd been sleeping or engaged in some sort of consensual activity. Therefore, I thought, perhaps the fact that the cause of the actual injury was somebody pulling the fixture off the wall -- something not at all work related -- was the reason why the injury was not compensable.

But that's not the way the Australian High Court saw it. The case is Comcare v PVYW, [2013] HCA 41.

The High Court's majority opinion states, at ¶60, "[F]or an injury occurring in an interval in a period of work to be in the course of employment, the circumstance in which an employee is injured must be connected to the inducement or encouragement of the employer. An inducement or encouragement to be at a particular place does not provide the necessary connection to employment merely because an employee is injured whilst engaged in an activity at that place." The Australian court concluded (¶61) that an injury will be compensable where it "was suffered by an employee whilst engaged in an activity in which the employer had induced or encouraged the employee to engage" or where the "injury was suffered at and by reference to a place where the employer had induced or encouraged the employee to be."

I wondered how an Illinois court might resolve a similar case.

As near as I could tell, there is no factually similar case in Illinois. But, after actually doing a little research, as opposed to merely speculating, it appears an Illinois court looking at similar facts would consider the injured woman a "traveling employee." According to Cox v. Illinois Worker's Compensation Commission, 406 Ill.App.3d 541, 545 (1st Dist 2010), "A 'traveling employee' is one who is required to travel away from his employer's premises in order to perform his job."

Cox explains, "The determination of whether an injury to a traveling employee arose out of and in the course of employment is governed by different rules than are applicable to other employees. * * * As a general rule, a traveling employee is held to be in the course of his employment from the time that he leaves home until he returns. * * * However, a finding that a claimant is a traveling employee does not relieve him from the burden of proving that his injury arose out of and in the course of employment. * * * The test for determining whether an injury to a traveling employee arose out of and in the course of his employment is the reasonableness of the conduct in which he was engaged and whether the conduct might normally be anticipated or foreseen by the employer. * * * Under such an analysis, a traveling employee may be compensated for an injury as long as the injury was sustained while he was engaged in an activity which was both reasonable and foreseeable." (406 Ill.App.3d at 545-6, citations omitted.)

My original notion that the case might turn on a question of intervening cause is pretty well put to rest by Potenzo v. Illinois Workers' Compensation Commission, 378 Ill.App.3d 113 (1st Dist. 2007).

In Potenzo, a driver making deliveries at a Jewel Food Store in Uptown was using a hand control, trying to lower two pallets of goods on a hydraulic-lift platform, "when he felt someone grab his ankle." As he turned to look, "he was hit in the back of the head, and he immediately lost consciousness." (378 Ill.App.3d at 114.)

The employer made what sounds to my non-specialist ears something like a causation argument, taking the position that the driver faced the same risk of getting mugged as anyone else out on the streets of Chicago. The employer argued that the driver "failed to carry his burden of establishing that, when assaulted on February 27, 1995, he was exposed to a greater danger than the general public, and as a consequence, failed to establish that his injuries arose out of his employment." (378 Ill.App.3d at 117.)

But the driver insisted that he was a traveling employee, required to unload trucks in alleys and loading docks at odd hours and, as such, "his employment 'caused him to incur the special risk of contact with street crime and violence' and, as a consequence, he was not required to establish that the risk of being attacked was peculiar to his employment, only that his employment exposed him to the same risk as the general public." (378 Ill.App.3d at 117.)

Under Illinois law, according to the Potenzo court, there are three types of risks to which a worker might be exposed (378 Ill.App.3d at 116):
  1. risks distinctly associated with the employment
  2. risks which are personal to the employee, and
  3. neutral risks which have no particular employment or personal characteristics
The risk that the driver might get unloaded on while attempting to unload was one of these "neutral risks." (378 Ill.App.3d at 117.) And the Potenzo court agreed that the driver could not establish why he was attacked, nor was the Appellate Court inclined to disagree with the Commission's finding that the driver failed to establish that he was working in a high crime area or dangerous neighborhood when he was attacked. (378 Ill.App.3d at 118.)

However, the Potenzo court concluded, "The undisputed evidence in this case establishes that the claimant was a traveling employee whose duties required him to travel the streets and unload a truck in areas accessible to the public. The risk of being assaulted, although one to which the general public is exposed, was a risk to which the claimant, by virtue to his employment, was exposed to a greater degree than the general public. * * * [T]here is no evidence in this case which would support an inference that the attack upon the claimant was based on a purely personal motive. Finally, it is undisputed that, when he was assaulted, the claimant was in the process of unloading his truck, an activity which was reasonably foreseeable by Jewel." (378 Ill.App.3d at 119.) The Appellate Court set aside the Commission's decision and ordered that benefits be awarded to the injured truck driver.

So intervening cause is definitely not an issue, but reasonableness and foreseeability are primary considerations that we might an expect an Illinois court to consider if a case similar to the Australian case arose in Illinois.

Therefore (again, speaking as a non-specialist), I have to suspect that an Illinois court evaluating such a case might find guidance in Howell Tractor & Equipment Co. v. Industrial Commission, 78 Ill. 2d 567 (1980).

In Howell Tractor, the soon-to-be injured employee and a colleague were dispatched to Logansport, Indiana to repair a road resurfacing machine. The duo picked up the spare parts they needed and headed to Logansport. They disassembled the machine, finding and fixing the problem they expected that same afternoon. But, as they were repairing the reported problem they saw that another part was missing from the motor. That, they reasoned, might be contributing to the overheating problem that gave rise to their service call. After consulting with the manufacturer, who suggested they tear down the motor again and made provisional arrangements to ship out a replacement motor if that failed, the Howell employees secured permission from their manager to stay overnight. (78 Ill.2d 570-571.)

They went out for dinner and drinks with the road project foreman. Then, borrowing clothes from the foreman, they drove out to one place, and then a different place, closing the second one. One of the Howell employees went to the bathroom, but when he came back he found that his comrades had left. The employee had never been to Logansport before, and he might have called a cab, but, somehow, he thought it might be a good idea to walk back to the motel. He soon realized he was lost, but then he remembered that there was a railroad crossing near the motel, so when he found some railroad tracks, he decided he just might find the motel if he walked alongside them. This proved to be as bad an idea as it sounds: The employee's arm was snagged by a passing train, and when he wriggled free and fell off, the train ran over his leg. (78 Ill.2d at 571-573.)

The Supreme Court found that the employee in this case was not entitled to benefits. The court explained, "Although the protection afforded a traveling employee by the [Act] * * * is considerably more extensive than that afforded other employees, the purposes of the Act do not require the employer to serve as an insurer for a traveling employee. * * * The burden of establishing compensability rests upon the claimant, and proof that he would not have been at the place where the injury occurred but for his employment is not alone sufficient." (78 Ill.2d at 574, citations omitted.)

Further explaining, the Howell Tractor court stated, "Assuming here that claimant's conduct in borrowing dressier clothes, showering and leaving the motel after 10 p.m. was reasonable and foreseeable, it ceased being so, in our judgment, when claimant decided to part with his companions and return to the motel alone. Although the claimant testified he thought he knew how to reach the motel, he had never been in Logansport before. He, [the foreman and his colleague] had driven a total of 20 minutes to reach the tavern where they parted. He didn't ask anyone for directions to the motel, nor did he inquire about the taxi service which was available. Instead, about 2 a.m. in the morning and after admittedly having five drinks, he set out on foot in an unsavory section of the town to reach his motel some three miles away without being certain which direction or how far it was. In our opinion that action is simply not reasonable, nor could an employer be expected to reasonably foresee that an employee would make such a rash decision." (78 Ill.2d at 574-5.)

The court concluded (78 Ill.2d at 575-6), "In the case now before us even though the initial decision to have a few drinks with [his comrades] is assumed to be unobjectionable, the decision to walk back to the motel resulted in a late-night excursion through an unfamiliar and potentially hazardous area.... Eschewing taxi service and guidance in locating the motel, [the employee] predictably became lost and, at that hour in the morning, apparently saw no one to assist him. As the arbitrator below decided, any conclusion that this rash course of conduct is reasonable and foreseeable is against the manifest weight of the evidence."

Even with these cases providing guidance, I can't begin to guess how an Illinois court might resolve a case similar to the one decided last week in Australia. If this case arose in Illinois, the result might have been different... although not, presumably, the giggling media coverage.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

For further reading: High Court rules out compensation to public servant injured while having sex in a motel (The Australian)

Australian loses compensation case for sex injury (AP coverage, this link to the Waterton, South Dakota Public Opinion)

Thursday, October 3, 2013

Government program beginning even though it's clearly not ready!

Do you know where your Ventra card is?
It occurs to me that the headline on this post may be misleading for out-of-town web searchers surfing the Ether for snark about Obamacare. Sorry, Red State visitors, but here in Chicago we have Ventra. (Cue scary music.)

It wasn't until last night, after reading 43rd Ward Ald. Michelle Smith's email newsletter, that I realized I won't be able to put any more money on my CTA Chicago Card as of Monday.

I'd received an email from the CTA -- some time ago, come to think of it -- telling me that my Ventra card would soon be arriving in the mail.

But it hasn't arrived.

At least it hasn't arrived in my mailbox.

According to the Chicago Tribune, it is entirely possible that CTA customer Dan Lasky may have gotten my Ventra card, and probably yours as well.

The Tribune website features this picture of Mr. Lasky's mailbox and the linked article notes that Mr. Lasky has been informed that he also has another 'tray' of mail waiting for him at the Post Office.

I have noticed some Ventra cards already in use. It's been hard to miss the people cursing, pounding, or jumping from turnstile to turnstile trying to find one that will read their super-duper high-tech Ventra card. And I've been reading the horror stories about multiple fares being deducted by the Ventra card without the customer's knowledge: The 'old fashioned' Chicago Card tells you your balance when you enter the turnstile; you can quickly verify that the machine has deducted the expected amount -- but there's nothing analogous on the Ventra system.

I know I'm supposed to be reassured by more recent press accounts that say that the initial glitches in the Ventra rollout have been fixed, but my 'early adapting' days ended forever many years ago when I purchased what today we'd call a notebook computer equipped with Microsoft Windows for Pen Computing Version 1.0. (Cue more scary music.)

I was hoping to stall Ventra off until at least Christmas.

Apparently that will be impossible.

Mr. Lasky, I'll be stopping by your apartment this evening looking for my #@$!& Ventra card....

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Justice James Epstein on NTNM



Appellate Court Justice James Epstein is one of Avy Meyers's guests on this week's edition of North Town News Magazine. NTNM is shown on CAN-TV 19 in Chicago on Thursdays at 7:30 p.m. and on Fridays at 2:30 p.m. In Evanston, NTNM airs on ECTV 6 on Thursdays at 5:00 p.m. and on Sundays at 10:30 p.m. NTNM airs on several other suburban cable systems; consult your local listings.

My thanks to Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew, Sonny Hersh, for allowing me to share Justice Epstein's NTNM appearance here.

My most recent appearance on NTNM


Avy Meyers was kind enough to invite me to appear recently on his North Town News Magazine program. This is that interview. My thanks also to Avy Meyers's entire technical crew, Sonny Hersh.

Saturday, August 31, 2013

Does the NSA really want to ban this t-shirt?


My son-in-law Arne called this story on Business Insider to my attention. The gist of Jim Edwards' story was that gift site Zazzle.com pulled the t-shirt shown here from its site in response to pressure from the National Security Agency. (Zazzle had been selling these shirts for Dan McCall, the shirt's designer.)

This evening, however, The Atlantic Wire reports, "The NSA Doesn't Mind Parody T-Shirts After All." According to Connor Simpson's article, Zazzle did receive a letter from the NSA... in 2011.

According to Simpson, the NSA advised The Daily Dot, the outlet that first broke this story, that "The NSA seal is protected by Public Law 86-36, which states that it is not permitted for '…any person to use the initials NSA, the words National Security Agency and the NSA seal without first acquiring written permission from the Director of NSA" (some internal quotation marks omitted). However, the NSA's letter to Zazzle, back in 2011 didn't concern this t-shirt (obviously, since it was designed after the Snowden revelations) but rather a mug which apparently used the NSA seal.

This is the real NSA logo.
Note that it says nothing about
peeping or sleeping.
Despite the careless language in the linked stories, the t-shirt in question was not using the actual NSA seal. The motto of the NSA isn't really "peeping while you're sleeping."

But that's OK. The NSA was also apparently careless in its use of language. The actual statute in question is 50 U.S.C. §3613 which provides, in subsection (a) (emphasis mine):
No person may, except with the written permission of the Director of the National Security Agency, knowingly use the words “National Security Agency”, the initials “NSA”, the seal of the National Security Agency, or any colorable imitation of such words, initials, or seal in connection with any merchandise, impersonation, solicitation, or commercial activity in a manner reasonably calculated to convey the impression that such use is approved, endorsed, or authorized by the National Security Agency.
I don't think anyone could possibly develop an impression that the t-shirt depicted in this post was in any way "approved, endorsed, or authorized" by the NSA.

Meanwhile, The Atlantic Wire says the shirt is now available for sale on Cafepress. Click over there and you'll be instantly persuaded that, if Mr. McCall didn't invent this entire controversy, he is certainly taking full, savvy-marketing advantage of it all. And he is certainly not trying to convey any impression that his shirts carry the NSA imprimatur.

Laughing about the NSA?

Screen capture from getprsm.com

I saw the reference to to the very funny getprsm.com site on someone's Facebook page. Given the subject matter thereof, I worried a little about mentioning my source... and finally didn't. They already know, I suppose, but why push it?

When Mr. Snowden made undeniably public what had so long been assumed (and feared) there were the inevitable editorial cartoons. Messrs. Luckovich and Oliphant, for example, weighed in before the end of July.



But editorial cartoonists are expected to have pungent opinions on any given day. They have new opinions, on different matters, just about every day.

But the revelations about the NSA weren't just any old story. It bothers a lot of us on a fundamental level. This can be illustrated in the way in which the story came up in far less political comics, like Dilbert and Dustin.



For those of us old enough to remember when the taking of an oath to preserve and defend the Constitution of the United States was a solemn promise to adhere to the letter and spirit of the document, this is one of those we-have-to-laugh-to-keep-from-crying stories. I thought this last cartoon, from a web comic called Doghouse Diaries, was particularly amusing.

But -- just in case someone in authority is thinking about it -- this sort of thing wouldn't make anything better as far as I'm concerned.

Thursday, August 15, 2013

Too busy right now, restauranteur tells would-be robbers -- come back in an hour


According to this UPI account, late Sunday night, Mario Garcia, 39, and Domingo Garcia-Hernandez, 28, went to a West Rogers Park restaurant, the Clifton Grill, brandishing a squirt gun, intent on robbing the place. (The Huffington Post account suggests that they merely demanded food on this first visit.)

Whatever they were after, they weren't willing to pay for it. Garcia and Garcia-Hernandez allegedly threatened the owner with grievous bodily harm if he did not accede to their demands.

The owner was nonplussed. He was just too busy to be robbed just now, he told them. Come back in an hour, he suggested, intimating that he'd be more amenable to a robbery then.

They left.

But an hour later, just as the owner recommended, the would-be robbers returned. The Huffington Post account says that, this time, Garcia and Garcia-Hernandez allegedly demanded $100 in addition to their takeout order.

The owner said, sure, but he needed to get his wife's checkbook. (Apparently the crooks didn't take MasterCard or Visa.) He excused himself, but he didn't look for a checkbook. He called the police instead.

The police came and collected Messrs. Garcia and Garcia-Hernandez, charging them with attempted aggravated robbery. Garcia-Hernandez was additionally charged with possession of a replica firearm; apparently he had the squirtgun.

Friday, August 2, 2013

I received this notice in my email recently


Repeating: I received this in my email.

So... Clerk Brown, am I registered or not? (And if I'm not, how did I get this?)

Well, I suppose I shall have to check. Somehow.

Sunday, July 28, 2013

Bank breaks into nurse's house, takes her stuff, but won't pay her back

Ohio homeowner Katie Barnett. Photo from ABC News.
I first saw the story on Popehat, "Want To Burglarize A House With Impunity, Then Nickle-And-Dime The Restitution? It Helps To Be A Bank."

Katie Barnett, a nurse in McArthur, Ohio, was away from home for a couple of weeks. While she was away, the First National Bank of Wellston, a local institution which had foreclosed on a house across the street, went to take possession of same. "Guided" by GPS (and neglecting to actually look at the house numbers on the mailboxes outside), the bank's "representatives" broke into Barnett's house, took most of her stuff, and changed the locks. When she got home, she had to gain access through a window. She called the police; the police theorized that perhaps squatters had got in.

But, no, the bank has admitted that it was the culprit. According to the ABC News account, the bank's involvement was only revealed when someone from the bank also called the police. Persisting in their inexplicable error, bank personnel complained that someone was living in the bank's house.*

The story has made national news because of the way the bank responded to Barnett's request to be reimbursed for the value of the stuff taken -- and discarded by the bank. Barnett told ABC that the bank took two dressers and clothing for her five children, as well as items from outside their home, including pool cleaning supplies and patio furniture. She has estimated her loss at $18,000, but the bank says there are inconsistencies between "the written list of items that [Barnett] provided to us and the value she assigned to those items" when compared to "the list and descriptions of items removed that was prepared by the employees who did the work." Barnett says the bank president told her that it would not "pay retail" for her lost stuff. She's got a lawyer, and a suit is probably going to have to be filed before the bank makes good.

If it ever does.

Barnett's suit would be governed by Ohio law. But the story got me wondering what remedies might be available to an Illinois resident in Barnett's unhappy situation.

It would appear that our hypothetical Illinois resident would have an action for conversion. "To state a cause of action for conversion, a plaintiff must prove that: (1) she has a right to the property at issue; (2) she has an absolute and unconditional right to the immediate possession of that property; (3) the defendant wrongfully and without authorization assumed control, dominion, or ownership over the property; and (4) she made a demand for the return of the property." Weisberger v. Weisberger, 2011 IL App (1st) 101557, ¶45. "Generally, the measure of damages for conversion is the market value of the property at the time of conversion." Long v. Arthur J. Rubloff & Co., 27 Ill.App.3d 1013, 1025, 327 N.E.2d 346 (1st Dist. 1975). Thus, if Barnett's case arose in Illinois, the Ohio bank president's Illinois counterpart would have a basis upon which to refuse to pay retail.

But the hypothetical Illinois bank would face a petty serious problem. Punitive damages are available for the tort of conversion. Cirrincione v. Johnson, 184 Ill.2d 109, 703 N.E.2d 67 (1998). In Cirrincione, punitive damages were affirmed in favor of a doctor against a lawyer on account of the lawyer's failure to honor his physician's lien when disbursing the proceeds of the settlement of a personal injury case. "Punitive damages are awarded 'when torts are committed with fraud, actual malice, * * * or when the defendant acts willfully, or with such gross negligence as to indicate a wanton disregard of the rights of others.'" Cirrincione, 184 Ill.2d 115-115, quoting Kelsay v. Motorola, Inc., 74 Ill.2d 172, 186, 384 N.E.2d 353 (1978). The bank's conduct here might well be thought of as more than sufficiently grossly negligent to qualify. If the law is similar in Ohio, the bank might do well to consider paying the $18,000 requested by Ms. Barnett.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The bank says that it figured out they had emptied the wrong house sooner than that. According to the bank's statement, "Unfortunately, we did not discover our error until the clean-up process was nearly complete." Then did the bank actually call the police to report Barnett as a trespasser in her own house or not? If it knew at an early date that it had made this terrible mistake, wouldn't the bank have notified the authorities -- or the homeowner -- sooner? You'd think that the local TV station would have verified these facts by checking with the local constabulary... but who knows?